“The moment they’re all in middle school, I feel like it’s just gonna be chaos,” the former NFL star said

Jason Kelce is getting candid about welcoming another baby girl into his family.

A few days after revealing his family’s reaction to the news that wife Kylie Kelce is expecting another girl, the former NFL star and ESPN host, 37, shared his thoughts about the news on The Rich Eisen Show.

“Fourth girl. I am screwed,” he joked.

“I’m screwed [in] like in 10 years,” he added. “The moment they’re all in middle school, I feel like it’s just gonna be chaos.”

Jason Kelce Reveals How He and Wife Kylie Are Getting Ready for Baby Girl No. 4 — and the ‘Most Challenging’ Part of Parenting
As for the dynamics of a fourth child in the mix, the former Philadelphia Eagles player noted that’s something the family is still coming to terms with.

“We’re still figuring out three too. So I guess at this point it’s —,” Jason said, to which Eisen offered, “playing zone defense?”

“Hopefully, Wyatt can start helping out a little bit more in a couple of … in a few months here,” he added, referring to his eldest daughter. He and Kylie also share Elliotte, 3, and Bennett, 21 months.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

A photo of Jason and Kylie Kelce with their three daughters Bennett, Elliotte and Wyatt

However, Jason conceded that there are a lot of positives that come with being a girl dad — especially when it comes to the father-daughter bond.

“I obviously have not had a son, but there is something about a daughter in the way I think as a dad, you feel an extra amount probably of protection and love toward that child,” he explained.

Jason Kelce Says Taylor Swift Has Been ‘Nothing but Lovely to Our Family’: ‘She’s a Wonderful Person’
On Nov. 22, Kylie revealed on Instagram that she and Jason are expecting another girl by sharing a photo of her three children’s reactions to the news. The three girls show a range of emotions, with Wyatt looking in disbelief as she cupped her hands to her head, Elliotte smiling wide for the camera and Bennett crying.

“I feel like we captured a very accurate representation of how each of the girls feel about getting another sister,” a pregnant Kylie wrote in the Instagram caption. “At least Ellie, mom and dad are on the same page! 🤷‍♀️”

In July 2024, Jason opened up about the possibility of a fourth child with his wife while speaking to PEOPLE at the American Century Championship presented by American Century Investments in Lake Tahoe. He noted at the time that the potential for another baby was “not my decision.”

“We’ve talked about, before having kids, having certain numbers, but I think whatever Kylie’s comfortable with,” he continued. “We’ll figure it out.”

Who Is Jeff Bezos’ Fiancée? 3 Things to Know About Lauren Sánchez